User:HaydenBobMutthew/Unintuitive crafting recipe list

From Minecraft Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Anyone can edit this page!
Although this is HaydenBobMutthew's user page, other users are encouraged to edit it and its subpages.
Note: This is my suggestion, don't take it too serious, as said by tryashtar, the recipes are designed for proper gameplay reasons,[1] but you can feel free to add any unintuitive crafting recipe.
If your edit is disallowed by an edit filter, please post your suggested changes on the talk page.

These lists note the crafting recipes that should probably be changed, with the reason provided.

Most common reasons:

  • Not proportional
  • It is not specific enough
  • Inconsistency between editions
  • Can be simplified
  • Not realistic

Blocks[edit]

Output Current Suggested Reason
Planks A bit more realistic, assuming the planks is hollow.
Wood Not proportional.[2]
Stairs Not proportional, also, the recipe don't reflect the 2-step nature of the stairs.
Crafting Table

The crafting table is made with oak and not proportional.
Furnace

Not proportional.
Dispenser


Not proportional.
Dropper


Not proportional.
Blast Furnace

Not proportional.
Smoker

Not proportional.
Fletching Table


The fletching table is made with birch and not proportional.
Smithing Table


The smithing table is seemingly made with dark oak and not proportional.
Cartography Table


The cartography table is made with dark oak and not proportional.
Chest

Not proportional.
Barrel Java Edition:


Bedrock Edition:


The barrel is made with spruce and not proportional.
Stonecutter

Stonecutter

Stonecutter
Not proportional.
Campfire

Not proportional.
Colored Wool Java Edition:


Bedrock Edition:

Inconsistent to terracotta and glass dyeing. Also, Bedrock Edition dyeing is a flaw in logic, since color will mix, but the recipe is not, a paradox.
Carpet Not proportional.
Bed


Not proportional and the base is made of oak.
Colored Bed


Bedrock Edition dyeing is a flaw in logic, since color will mix, but the recipe is not, a paradox.
Wooden Trapdoor Not proportional.
Composter Java Edition:


Bedrock Edition:


Not proportional.
Piston


Not proportional and the arm is made of oak.
Redstone Repeater


Not proportional and the base of redstone repeater is made of smooth stone, not stone.
Redstone Comparator


Not proportional and the base of redstone comparator is made of smooth stone, not stone.
Redstone Lamp


Not proportional.
Daylight Detector


Not proportional and more realistic, in parity with clock.
Hopper


Not proportional and the chest is unnecessary.
Observer


Not proportional.
Button


Not proportional.
Note Block


Not proportional.
Jukebox


Not proportional.
TNT

Not proportional, also sand and red sand can be both used.
Brewing Stand


Not proportional.
Glowstone


Consistency to redstone block.
Beacon


Not proportional.
Loom


Not proportional.
Lectern


The lectern is made with oak and not proportional.
Rail Not proportional.
Glass Pane Not proportional.
Diorite

Inconsistent to Granite.
Wood Door

Not proportional.
Iron Door


Not proportional.
Ender Chest


Not proportional.
Snow Not proportional.
Snow Block


As a full snow (snow with 8 layers) drops 8 snowball, so the recipe. Also, snow block should drop 8 snowballs instead of 4.
Beehive


The beehive is made with oak and not proportional.

Items[edit]

Output Current Suggested Reason
Stick

Not proportional.
Clock


Clock in real-life have quartz to make timekeeping accurate and not proportional.
Bowl

Not proportional.
Glowstone Consistency to redstone dust.
Cake


There is a big berry on the top of the cake.[3]
Bucket


Resolve crafting conflict with hopper.
Item Frame


Not proportional.

References[edit]